Foodie Guide To Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Food from Friar’s Nook – our top pick for Not-So-Scary Party Exclusive food for 2024 & 2025!
Friar’s Nook has been a hit in our books for the last few years! Returning Party Exclusives:

Bowl of Bones, $13.49 in 2025: Pork wings fried with jalapeños and tossed in barbecue sauce made with Coca-Cola Cherry. Get two. Sticky, sweet, and a zesty punch if you eat the jalapeños. Less fire if you ask for them to be omitted when you order.
Buffalo Chicken Hand Pie, $9.99 in 2025: Buffalo chicken and mozzarella wrapped in a flaky dough topped with blue cheese crumbles and Buffalo-ranch. Ohhhhhhhweeeee! We LOVE this one! It’s a traditional Buffalo twang! Do you remember the original Buffalo sauce from the owl wing place? This sauce is like that but add in the blue cheese crumbles and wow. Don’t skip this one.
Haunting Jalapeño Tots, $10.49 in 2025: Tots topped with plant-based black bean chili, cheddar sauce, and jalapeño sauce. These tots had a lot of kick, so beware if you’re feeding little folks or anyone without a spice tolerance.
Not-So-Poison Apple Doughnuts, $6.49 in 2025: Rolled in apple cider sugar and drizzled with caramel sauce. Friends. If you are only going to get one sweet treat (other than your 22lbs of candy) make it this one. We STILL talk about these doughnuts nearly a year later and it sure was the first thing our team checked when we saw that Disney released the list of party food.

Pinocchio Village Haus

Open until 10pm
5 PE items

Sleepy Hollow Refreshments

Open until midnight
4 PE items

Pecos Bill Tall Tale Inn and Cafe

Open until 10pm
6 PE items

Buzzard Wings from Pecos Bill
The Buzzard Wings from Pecos Bill’s are coming back this year! They were $11.99 last year and ended up being one of our favorite plates of the night. The presentation of the whole chicken wings is on the creepy side, but the lime, grilled onions, and jalapeños were heavenly.
Golden Oak Outpost

Open until midnight
3 PE items

There are two Table Service locations that have Party Exclusive menus:
Cinderella’s Royal Table is available for Not-So-Scary guests starting at 4pm. There are 6 items that are exclusive to the party menu at this location.
Be Our Guest is also available for party guests starting at 4pm. There are 4 items that are exclusive to the party menu.
The Plaza Restaurant has Halloween-themed menu items, but they are served all day.
If you’re headed to Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party this year, you may want to check out:
Touring Plan for Families with Small Children
Or, have a look at Everything We Ate at the 2025 Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party
Stay tuned for our posts after the first party on August 7th! We’ll show you treat stop locations, entertainment, the Boo to You parade, and our picks for the best party food!

Related Posts